Lizzie Borden took an axe and gave her mother forty whacks. When she saw what she had done, she gave her father fortyones, a skipping rope rhyme that rolled right off the tongues of many children over 120 years ago. A rhyme that told the gruesome endings of Andrew and Abby Borden’s lives. Leading to a case that was left a mystery and hundreds of unanswered questions. Even after so many years people still want answers. But the main questions are could Lizzie Borden be responsible for the murder of her own parents? And are women capable of such a gruesome act?
It states in The New Yorker that “about one in every six serial killers are women” and with more research Marissa Harrison and her colleagues identified “female serial killers that were active between 1821 and 2008″(The New Yorker). There was nothing out of the ordinary about the women that they researched, no mental illness and no reason behind their multiple murders. On August 4 of 1892, the bodies of Andrew Borden, age 69, and second wife Abby Borden, age 65, were found in their Fall River, Massachusetts home(Cheree). Andrew was found first by 32 year old, Lizzie Borden, the youngest of his two daughters.
He was found lying to on the couch in the downstairs sitting room where he takes his routined naps. His face had been hacked into fragments with a hatchet and he was barely recognizable(Walter 61). He sustained 12 cuts in the face and skull( Walter 56). Later, second wife Abby Borden was found lying face down on the floor in the guest bedroom by neighbor Adelaide Churchill, who was there to comfort Miss Borden while police were looking for signs of an intruder(Linder). She suffered and died from multiple blows to the back of her head, also from a hatchet. It was recorded that Abby Borden was killed around 9:30, And Andrew an hour or so later.
During the time of the murders Lizzie Borden and, maid Bridget Sullivan, better known as “Maggie” by the family, were recorded to be at the Fall River’s home. Lizzie told prosecutor that she was in the barn during the time of the murder. After eating three pears she went to the second floor of the barn to look for sinkers for a fishing trip that was days away(Koorey), and Bridget Sullivan was noted to have been lying in bed after she finished washing windows when ordered by Abby to do so(Linder). It was reported that when Lizzie called for Bridget after finding her father’s body that she did not cry nor did she seem in shocked.
Soon all eyes were on Lizzie as police believed her to be the killer. Lizzie Borden was arrested on August 11 as the prime suspect. As time passed the newspapers were sending out equations and detectives would follow upon them. For example it was said that Lizzie went to a drug store in attempt to buy a diluted sample of very deadly prussic acid 36 hours before the murders(Walter 64). It was thought that she poisoned her family since she was the only one in the household to not get sick, but like most claims they all lead to a dead end.
It seems as if the press sent police on a wild goose chase to either prove Lizzie’s innocence or find the person responsible. None of the evidence held up in court. Soon the press made it a battle of masculine versus feminine. During this time period women were seen as emotional beings that acted off of their feelings and not off of logic and so a in the minds of men, women did not have the potential to kill not only one person, but two, and not leave a single trace. Lizzie Borden made people question gender norms and rethink what women could possible be capable of. Women were seen as weak compared to men and had little rights.
Femininity was defined by possessing qualities traditionally attributed to women such as demureness(Collins English Dictionary). Demureness means to be modest and reserved in manner or behavior(American Heritage Dictionary). Lizzie did posses qualities of a woman but most of all her demeanor throughout the entire case said otherwise. Her reaction to the death of her parents was almost emotionless, which some would say were masculine qualities and suggested her to be guilty. overall the feminine descriptions of Miss Borden seemed to have won the heart of the press and public and court(Walter 78).
The jury of 12 men had reached the verdict that said Lizzie Borden is “Not Guilty”. With in my research have come up with my own theory of how this murder played out, but I did not change my views on who did it. I believe the killer to be Lizzie Borden, but I also believe that she had someone that she knew would not become a suspect of the case to help her. I think Lizzie wanted her father dead so that she and her sister could inherit his money and estate. It is said that Andrew was one who was a little stingy with his wealth especially when it came to his children.
But killing just him was not enough, because it was still a possibility that most of the money could have went to second wife Addy, so they killed her too. In a police statement it is said that the killer might be a tall male based on the damage that was done to the back of Abby’s head. I think this male could have been Lizzies half brother William Borden who was not financially stable and tried previous to get money out of his illegitimate father, but it was a failed attempted. So when Lizzie offered him a way into the fortune he took it, and all he had to do was kill Andrew and Abby and just leave.
It is unlikely for him to be a suspect because he is never with the family and is rarely talked about. I think that William was already in the house before Andrew had arrived back to the house. Soon Lizzie told him that Abby had to leave to go visit a sick friend in town so that he would not look for her before letting William kill her. Then once Andrew laid down for his routine nape, and was well enough into his sleep, William had the opportunity to kill him, and that is why Andrew was not kill until an hour and a half after Abby.
Then William left and let Lizzie handle the rest, so all he had to do was kill Andrew and Abby and leave taking the evidence with him. This is also why there was no evidence of a forced entry because the door was open for him. Henceforth pulling off one of the greatest axe murders of all time. Lizzie Borden’s case was one of many that showed how society view women. They were often underestimated and overlooked. Women were seen as emotional beings not capable of committing such an act, and for Lizzie Borden this idea worked in her favor and helped her get away with a double-murder.